Abstract
Using examples to inspire designers to generate more innovative design solutions is a widely adopted methodology for design support, while inappropriate use of examples may simultaneously lead to design fixation. Once a designer falls into “design fixation” in the design process, the novelty of generated design solutions will not be satisfactory. Numerous prior studies have explored the usage of examples in the design process, while ignoring the importance of the background knowledge possessed by the designer. In this study, we performed a series of designer-involved experiments (N = 57) to explore the sources of design fixation and the factors that influence the level of fixation. From the experimental results, we found: (1) the shallow sources of design fixation are the example stimuli and the deeper sources are the previous design solutions that use the same design features. (2) Fixation-design features linkage diagrams could show the connection between design solutions. (3) For novice designers, using broad-type design features other than focused-type design features in the design processes can lead to better design performance. (4) Design-type knowledge contributes more to design innovation when no examples are provided, while engineering-type knowledge performs better when a model example is provided. These results not only show a strong link between design features and design fixation but also present the importance of professional background for design fixation. This study lays the foundation for proposing various targeted design methods to help designers mitigate fixation.
References
1.
Jansson
, D. G.
, and Smith
, S. M.
, 1991
, “Design Fixation
,” Des. Stud.
, 12
(1
), pp. 3
–11
. 2.
Agogué
, M.
, Poirel
, M.
, Pineau
, N.
, Houdé
, A.
, and Cassotti
, O.
, 2014
, “The Impact of Age and Training on Creativity: A Design-Theory Approach to Study Fixation Effects
,” Think. Skills Creat.
, 11
, pp. 33
–41
. 3.
Neroni
, M. A.
, and Crilly
, N.
, 2020
, “How to Guard Against Fixation? Demonstrating Individual Vulnerability Is More Effective Than Warning of General Risk
,” J. Creat. Behav.
, 55
(2
), pp. 1
–17
. 4.
Viswanathan
, V.
, and Linsey
, J.
, 2020
, “Designing With Examples: A Study on the Role of Familiarity, Warnings and Physical Modelling
,” J. Eng. Des.
, 31
(11–12
), pp. 552
–573
. 5.
Leahy
, K.
, Daly
, S. R.
, McKilligan
, S.
, and Seifert
, C. M.
, 2020
, “Design Fixation From Initial Examples: Provided Versus Self-Generated Ideas
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 142
(10
), p. 101402
. 6.
McComb
, C.
, Cagan
, J.
, and Kotovsky
, K.
, 2015
, “Lifting the Veil: Drawing Insights About Design Teams From a Cognitively-Inspired Computational Model
,” Des. Stud.
, 40
, pp. 119
–142
. 7.
Chan
, J.
, Fu
, K.
, Schunn
, C.
, Cagan
, J.
, Wood
, K.
, and Kotovsky
, K.
, 2011
, “On the Benefits and Pitfalls of Analogies for Innovative Design: Ideation Performance Based on Analogical Distance, Commonness, and Modality of Examples
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 133
(8
), p. 081004
. 8.
Goucher-Lambert
, K.
, Gyory
, J. T.
, Kotovsky
, K.
, and Cagan
, J.
, 2020
, “Adaptive Inspirational Design Stimuli: Using Design Output to Computationally Search for Stimuli That Impact Concept Generation
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 142
(9
), p. 091401
. 9.
Miller
, S.
, Chang
, C.-C.
, Krantzler
, J.
, and Bailey
, B.
, 2009
, “Getting Inspired!: Understanding How and Why Examples Are Used in Creative Design Practice
,” Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems
, Boston, MA
, Apr. 4–9
, pp. 87
–96
.10.
Cardoso
, C.
, and Badke-Schaub
, P.
, 2009
, “Idea Fixation in Design: The Infuence of Pictures and Words
,” Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Research Into Design
, Bangalore, India
, Jan. 7–9
.11.
Atilola
, O.
, and Linsey
, J.
, 2015
, “Representing Analogies to Influence Fixation and Creativity: A Study Comparing Computer-Aided Design, Photographs, and Sketches
,” Artif. Intell. Eng. Des. Anal. Manuf.
, 29
(2
), pp. 161
–171
. 12.
Viswanathan
, V. K.
, and Linsey
, J. S.
, 2012
, “Physical Models and Design Thinking: A Study of Functionality, Novelty and Variety of Ideas
,” ASME. J. Mech. Des.
, 134
(9
), p. 091004
. 13.
Toh
, C. A.
, and Miller
, S. R.
, 2014
, “The Impact of Example Modality and Physical Interactions on Design Creativity
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 136
(9
), p. 091004
. 14.
Fu
, K.
, Chan
, J.
, Cagan
, J.
, Kotovsky
, K.
, Schunn
, C.
, and Wood
, K.
, 2013
, “The Meaning of ‘Near’ and ‘Far’: The Impact of Structuring Design Databases and the Effect of Distance of Analogy on Design Output
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 135
(2
), p. 021007
. 15.
Tseng
, I.
, Moss
, J.
, Cagan
, J.
, and Kotovsky
, K.
, 2008
, “The Role of Timing and Analogical Similarity in the Stimulation of Idea Generation in Design
,” Des. Stud.
, 29
(3
), pp. 203
–221
. 16.
Goucher-Lambert
, K.
, and Cagan
, J.
, 2019
, “Crowdsourcing Inspiration: Using Crowd Generated Inspirational Stimuli to Support Designer Ideation
,” Des. Stud.
, 61
, pp. 1
–29
. 17.
Behoora
, I.
, and Tucker
, C. S.
, 2015
, “Machine Learning Classification of Design Team Members’ Body Language Patterns for Real Time Emotional State Detection
,” Des. Stud.
, 39
, pp. 100
–127
. 18.
Maier
, N. R. F.
, 1931
, “Reasoning in Humans. II. The Solution of a Problem and Its Appearance in Consciousness
,” J. Comp. Psychol.
, 12
(2
), pp. 181
–194
. 19.
Duncker
, K.
, 1945
, “On Problem-Solving
,” Psychol. Monogr.
, 58
(5
), pp. i
–113
. 20.
Luchins
, A. S.
, 1942
, “Mechanization in Problem Solving: The Effect of Einstellung
,” Psychol. Monogr.
, 54
(6
), pp. i
–95
. 21.
Ward
, T. B.
, 1994
, “Structured Imagination: The Role of Category Structure in Exemplar Generation
,” Cogn. Psychol.
, 27
(1
), pp. 1
–40
. 22.
Marsh
, R. L.
, and Bower
, G. H.
, 1993
, “Eliciting Cryptomnesia: Unconscious Plagiarism in a Puzzle Task
,” J. Exp. Psychol. Learn. Mem. Cogn.
, 19
(3
), pp. 673
–688
. 23.
Marsh
, R. L.
, and Landau
, J. D.
, 1995
, “Item Availability in Cryptomnesia: Assessing Its Role in Two Paradigms of Unconscious Plagiarism
,” J. Exp. Psychol. Learn. Mem. Cogn.
, 21
(6
), pp. 1568
–1582
. 24.
Lopes Cordeiro
, J. M.
, 2011
, “The Man Behind Tua Railways: The Chief Engineer Dinis da Mota
,” Railr. Hist. Context Constr. Costs Consequences
, 13
, pp. 145
–182
.25.
Marsh
, R. L.
, Bink
, M. L.
, and Hicks
, J. L.
, 1999
, “Conceptual Priming in a Generative Problem-Solving Task
,” Mem. Cogn.
, 27
(2
), pp. 355
–363
. 26.
Crilly
, N.
, 2019
, “Methodological Diversity and Theoretical Integration: Research in Design Fixation as an Example of Fixation in Research Design?
,” Des. Stud.
, 65
, pp. 78
–106
. 27.
Youmans
, R. J.
, and Arciszewski
, T.
, 2014
, “Design Fixation: Classifications and Modern Methods of Prevention
,” Artif. Intell. Eng. Des. Anal. Manuf.
, 28
(2
), pp. 129
–137
. 28.
Vasconcelos
, L. A.
, and Crilly
, N.
, 2016
, “Inspiration and Fixation: Questions, Methods, Findings, and Challenges
,” Des. Stud.
, 42
, pp. 1
–32
. 29.
Sio
, U. N.
, Kotovsky
, K.
, and Cagan
, J.
, 2015
, “Fixation or Inspiration? A Meta-Analytic Review of the Role of Examples on Design Processes
,” Des. Stud.
, 39
, pp. 70
–99
. 30.
Crilly
, N.
, and Moroşanu Firth
, R.
, 2019
, “Creativity and Fixation in the Real World: Three Case Studies of Invention, Design and Innovation
,” Des. Stud.
, 64
, pp. 169
–212
. 31.
Purcell
, A. T.
, and Gero
, J. S.
, 1996
, “Design and Other Types of Fixation
,” Des. Stud.
, 17
(4
), pp. 363
–383
. 32.
Chrysikou
, E. G.
, and Weisberg
, R. W.
, 2005
, “Following the Wrong Footsteps: Fixation Effects of Pictorial Examples in a Design Problem-Solving Task
,” J. Exp. Psychol. Learn. Mem. Cogn.
, 31
(5
), pp. 1134
–1148
. 33.
Crilly
, N.
, 2019
, “Creativity and Fixation in the Real World: A Literature Review of Case Study Research
,” Des. Stud.
, 64
, pp. 154
–168
. 34.
Cai
, H.
, Do
, E. Y.-L.
, and Zimring
, C. M.
, 2010
, “Extended Linkography and Distance Graph in Design Evaluation: An Empirical Study of the Dual Effects of Inspiration Sources in Creative Design
,” Des. Stud.
, 31
(2
), pp. 146
–168
. 35.
Koh
, E. C. Y.
, and De Lessio
, M. P.
, 2018
, “Fixation and Distraction in Creative Design: The Repercussions of Reviewing Patent Documents to Avoid Infringement
,” Res. Eng. Des.
, 29
(3
), pp. 351
–366
. 36.
Cardoso
, C.
, and Badke-Schaub
, P. E. T. R. A.
, 2011
, “The Influence of Different Pictorial Representations During Idea Generation
,” J. Creat. Behav.
, 45
(2
), pp. 130
–146
. 37.
Jiang
, S.
, Luo
, J.
, Ruiz-Pava
, G.
, Hu
, J.
, and Magee
, C. L.
, 2021
, “Deriving Design Feature Vectors for Patent Images Using Convolutional Neural Networks
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 143
(6
), p. 061405
. 38.
Jiang
, S.
, Hu
, J.
, Wood
, K. L.
, and Luo
, J.
, 2022
, “Data-Driven Design-By-Analogy: State-of-the-Art and Future Directions
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 144
(2
), p. 020801
. 39.
Jiang
, S.
, Sarica
, S.
, Song
, B.
, Hu
, J.
, and Luo
, J.
, 2022
, “Patent Data for Engineering Design: A Critical Review and Future Directions
,” ASME J. Comput. Inf. Sci. Eng.
, 22
(6
), p. 060902
. 40.
Vasconcelos
, L. A.
, and Crilly
, N.
, 2016
, “Inspiration and Fixation: Questions, Methods, Findings, and Challenges
,” Des. Stud.
, 42
, pp. 1
–32
. 41.
Alipour
, L.
, Faizi
, M.
, Moradi
, A. M.
, and Akrami
, G.
, 2018
, “A Review of Design Fixation: Research Directions and Key Factors
,” Int. J. Des. Creat. Innov.
, 6
(1–2
), pp. 22
–35
. 42.
Dahl
, D. W.
, and Moreau
, P.
, 2002
, “The Influence and Value of Analogical Thinking During New Product Ideation
,” J. Mark. Res.
, 39
(1
), pp. 47
–60
. 43.
Jaarsveld
, S.
, and van Leeuwen
, C.
, 2005
, “Sketches From a Design Process: Creative Cognition Inferred From Intermediate Products
,” Cogn. Sci.
, 29
(1
), pp. 79
–101
. 44.
Marsh
, R. L.
, Ward
, T. B.
, and Landau
, J. D.
, 1999
, “The Inadvertent Use of Prior Knowledge in a Generative Cognitive Task
,” Mem. Cogn.
, 27
(1
), pp. 94
–105
. 45.
Smith
, S. M.
, 1995
, “Getting Into and Out of Mental Ruts: A Theory of Fixation, Incubation, and Insight,” The Nature of Insight
, R. J.
Sternberg
and J. E.
Davidson
, eds., The MIT Press
, Cambridge, MA
, pp. 229
–251
.46.
Smith
, S. M.
, Ward
, T. B.
, and Schumacher
, J. S.
, 1993
, “Constraining Effects of Examples in a Creative Generation Task
,” Mem. Cognit.
, 21
(6
), pp. 837
–845
. 47.
Jang
, J.
, and Schunn
, C. D.
, 2012
, “Physical Design Tools Support and Hinder Innovative Engineering Design
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 134
(4
), p. 041001
. 48.
Feng
, T.
, Cheong
, H.
, and Shu
, L. H.
, 2014
, “Effects of Abstraction on Selecting Relevant Biological Phenomena for Biomimetic Design
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 136
(11
), p. 111111
. 49.
Brown
, V.
, Tumeo
, M.
, Larey
, T. S.
, and Paulus
, P. B.
, 1998
, “Modeling Cognitive Interactions During Group Brainstorming
,” Small Group Res.
, 29
(4
), pp. 495
–526
. 50.
Coskun
, H.
, Paulus
, P. B.
, Brown
, V.
, and Sherwood
, J. J.
, 2000
, “Cognitive Stimulation and Problem Presentation in Idea-Generating Groups
,” Group Dyn. Theory Res. Pract.
, 4
(4
), p. 307
. 51.
Dugosh
, K. L.
, and Paulus
, P. B.
, 2005
, “Cognitive and Social Comparison Processes in Brainstorming
,” J. Exp. Soc. Psychol.
, 41
(3
), pp. 313
–320
. 52.
Goldschmidt
, G.
, and Smolkov
, M.
, 2006
, “Variances in the Impact of Visual Stimuli on Design Problem Solving Performance
,” Des. Stud.
, 27
(5
), pp. 549
–569
. 53.
Perttula
, M.
, and Sipilä
, P.
, 2007
, “The Idea Exposure Paradigm in Design Idea Generation
,” J. Eng. Des.
, 18
(1
), pp. 93
–102
. 54.
Perttula
, M. K.
, and Liikkanen
, L. A.
, 2006
, “Exposure Effects in Design Idea Generation: Unconscious Conformity or a Product of Sampling Probability?
,” Paper Presented at the NordDesign 2006
, Reykjavik, Iceland
, Aug. 16–18
, pp. 42
–55
.55.
Liikkanen
, L. A.
, and Perttula
, M.
, 2010
, “Inspiring Design Idea Generation: Insights From a Memory-Search Perspective
,” J. Eng. Des.
, 21
(5
), pp. 545
–560
. 56.
Fu
, K.
, Cagan
, J.
, and Kotovsky
, K.
, 2010
, “Design Team Convergence: The Influence of Example Solution Quality
,” ASME. J. Mech. Des.
, 132
(11
), p. 111005
. 57.
Hannah
, R.
, Joshi
, S.
, and Summers
, J. D.
, 2012
, “A User Study of Interpretability of Engineering Design Representations
,” J. Eng. Des.
, 23
(6
), pp. 443
–468
. 58.
Viswanathan
, V.
, Tomko
, M.
, and Linsey
, J.
, 2016
, “A Study on the Effects of Example Familiarity and Modality on Design Fixation
,” Artif. Intell. Eng. Des. Anal. Manuf.
, 30
(2
), pp. 171
–184
. 59.
Crilly
, N.
, 2015
, “Fixation and Creativity in Concept Development: The Attitudes and Practices of Expert Designers
,” Des. Stud.
, 38
, pp. 54
–91
. 60.
Siangliulue
, P.
, Chan
, J.
, Gajos
, K. Z.
, and Dow
, S. P.
, 2015
, “Providing Timely Examples Improves the Quantity and Quality of Generated Ideas
,” 2015 Proc. 2015 ACM SIGCHI Conference Creativity and Cognition
, Glasgow, UK
, June 22–25
, pp. 83
–92
.61.
Goldschmidt
, G.
, 2011
, “Avoiding Design Fixation: Transformation and Abstraction in Mapping From Source to Target
,” J. Creat. Behav.
, 45
(2
), pp. 92
–100
. 62.
Linsey
, J. S.
, Tseng
, I.
, Fu
, K.
, Cagan
, J.
, Wood
, K. L.
, and Schunn
, C.
, 2010
, “A Study of Design Fixation, Its Mitigation and Perception in Engineering Design Faculty
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 132
(4
), p. 041003
. 63.
Purcell
, A. T.
, and Gero
, J. S.
, 1991
, “The Effects of Examples on the Results of a Design Activity,” Artificial Intelligence in Design’91
, J. S.
Gero
, ed., Elsevier
, Edinburgh, UK
, pp. 525
–542
.64.
Kwon
, E.
, Ryan
, J. D.
, Bazylak
, A.
, and Shu
, L. H.
, 2019
, “Does Visual Fixation Affect Idea Fixation?
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 142
(3
), p. 031118
. 65.
McKoy
, F. L.
, Vargas-Hernández
, N.
, Summers
, J. D.
, and Shah
, J. J.
, 2001
, “Influence of Design Representation on Effectiveness of Idea Generation
,” International Design Engineering Technical Conferences and Computers and Information in Engineering Conference
, Pittsburgh, PA
, Sept. 9–12
, pp. 39
–48
.66.
Viswanathan
, V. K.
, and Linsey
, J. S.
, 2010
, “Physical Models in Idea Generation: Hindrance or Help?
,” International Design Engineering Technical Conferences and Computers and Information in Engineering Conference
, Montreal, Quebec, Canada
, Aug. 15–18
, pp. 329
–339
.67.
Kiriyama
, T.
, and Yamamoto
, T.
, 1998
, “Strategic Knowledge Acquisition: A Case Study of Learning Through Prototyping
,” Knowledge Based Syst.
, 11
(7–8
), pp. 399
–404
. 68.
Dijk
, L.
, Vergeest
, J. S. M.
, and Horváth
, I.
, 1998
, “Testing Shape Manipulation Tools Using Abstract Prototypes
,” Des. Stud.
, 19
(2
), pp. 187
–201
. 69.
Ahmed
, S.
, Wallace
, K. M.
, and Blessing
, L. T.
, 2003
, “Understanding the Differences Between How Novice and Experienced Designers Approach Design Tasks
,” Res. Eng. Des.
, 14
(1
), pp. 1
–11
. 70.
Kim
, J.
, and Ryu
, H.
, 2014
, “A Design Thinking Rationality Framework: Framing and Solving Design Problems in Early Concept Generation
,” Human–Comput. Interact.
, 29
(5–6
), pp. 516
–553
. 71.
Viswanathan
, V.
, and Linsey
, J.
, 2012
, “A Study on the Role of Expertise in Design Fixation and its Mitigation
,” Proc. ASME Des. Eng. Tech. Conf.
, 7
, pp. 901
–911
. 72.
Yuan
, P.
, Li
, Y.
, Chen
, J.
, Xiong
, Y.
, and Liu
, L.
, 2018
, “Experimental Study on the Associations Among Sketches Based on Design Cognition
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 140
(10
), p. 101102
. 73.
Sachs
, A.
, 1999
, “‘Stuckness’ in the Design Studio
,” Des. Stud.
, 20
(2
), pp. 195
–209
. 74.
Cross
, N.
, 2001
, “Design Cognition: Results From Protocol and Other Empirical Studies of Design Activity
,” Des. Know. Learn. Cogn. Des. Educ.
, pp. 79
–103
. 75.
Kavakli
, M.
, and Gero
, J. S.
, 2003
, “Strategic Knowledge Differences Between an Expert and a Novice Designer,” Human Behaviour in Design
, Ing. U.
Lindemann
, ed., Springer
, Berlin/Heidelberg
, pp. 42
–52
.76.
Coley
, F.
, Houseman
, O.
, and Roy
, R.
, 2007
, “An Introduction to Capturing and Understanding the Cognitive Behaviour of Design Engineers
,” J. Eng. Des.
, 18
(4
), pp. 311
–325
. 77.
Suwa
, M.
, Gero
, J. S.
, and Purcell
, T.
, 1998
, “The Roles of Sketches in Early Conceptual Design Processes
,” Proceedings of Twentieth Annual Meeting of the Cognitive Science Society
, pp. 1043
–1048
.78.
Ball
, L. J.
, Evans
, J. S. B. T.
, and Dennis
, I.
, 1994
, “Cognitive Processes in Engineering Design: A Longitudinal Study
,” Ergonomics
, 37
(11
), pp. 1753
–1786
. 79.
Ullman
, D. G.
, Dietterich
, T. G.
, and Stauffer
, L. A.
, 1988
, “A Model of the Mechanical Design Process Based on Empirical Data
,” Ai Edam
, 2
(1
), pp. 33
–52
. 80.
Viswanathan
, V. K.
, and Linsey
, J. S.
, 2013
, “Design Fixation and Its Mitigation: A Study on the Role of Expertise
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 135
(5
), pp. 1
–15
. 81.
Niku
, S. B.
, 2009
, “Creative Design of Products and Systems
,” Globalization
, 6
, pp. 3
–10
.82.
Viswanathan
, V.
, and Linsey
, J.
, 2011
, “Design Fixation in Physical Modeling: An Investigation on the Role of Sunk Cost
,” Proc. ASME Des. Eng. Tech. Conf.
, 9
, pp. 119
–130
. 83.
Toh
, C.
, Miller
, S.
, and Kremer
, G.
, 2014
, “Mitigating Design Fixation Effects in Engineering Design Through Product Dissection Activities,” Design Computing and Cognition’12
, J. S.
Gero
, ed., Springer
, Dordrecht
, pp. 95
–113
.84.
Shah
, J. J.
, Smith
, S. M.
, and Vargas-Hernandez
, N.
, 2003
, “Metrics for Measuring Ideation Effectiveness
,” Des. Stud.
, 24
(2
), pp. 111
–134
. 85.
Moreno
, D. P.
, Hernández
, A. A.
, Yang
, M. C.
, Otto
, K. N.
, Hölttä-Otto
, K.
, Linsey
, J. S.
, Wood
, K. L.
, and Linden
, A.
, 2014
, “Fundamental Studies in Design-by-Analogy: A Focus on Domain-Knowledge Experts and Applications to Transactional Design Problems
,” Des. Stud.
, 35
(3
), pp. 232
–272
. 86.
Viswanathan
, V. K.
, Esposito
, N. E.
, and Linsey
, J. S.
, 2012
, “Training Tomorrow’s Designers: A Study on the Design Fixation
,” ASEE Annu. Conference Expo. Conf. Proc.
, San Antonio, TX
, June 10
, pp. 25.1372.1–25.1372.13.87.
Cohen
, J.
, 1960
, “A Coefficient of Agreement for Nominal Scales
,” Educ. Psychol. Meas.
, 20
(1
), pp. 37
–46
. 88.
Belaziz
, M.
, Bouras
, A.
, and Brun
, J. M.
, 2000
, “Morphological Analysis for Product Design
,” Comput. Des.
, 32
(5
), pp. 377
–388
. 89.
Haley
, S. M.
and Osberg
, J. S.
, 1989
, “Kappa Coefficient Calculation Using Multiple Ratings Per Subject: A Special Communication
,” Phys. Therapy
, 69
(11
), pp. 970
–974
. 90.
Cai
, H.
, Do
, E. Y. L.
, and Zimring
, C. M. M.
, 2010
, “Extended Linkography and Distance Graph in Design Evaluation: An Empirical Study of the Dual Effects of Inspiration Sources in Creative Design
,” Des. Stud.
, 31
(2
), pp. 146
–168
. 91.
Cardoso
, C. C.
and Badke-Schaub
, P.
, 2009
, “Give Design a Break? The Role of Incubation Periods During Idea Generation
,” DS 58-2: Proceedings of ICED 09, the 17th International Conference on Engineering Design, Vol. 2, Design Theory and Research Methodology
, Palo Alto, CA
, Aug. 24–27
, pp. 383
–394
.Copyright © 2022 by ASME
You do not currently have access to this content.
