0
TECHNICAL PAPERS

Tissue-Level Thresholds for Axonal Damage in an Experimental Model of Central Nervous System White Matter Injury

[+] Author and Article Information
Allison C. Bain, David F. Meaney

Department of Bioengineering, 120 Hayden Hall, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA 19104-6392

J Biomech Eng 122(6), 615-622 (Jul 24, 2000) (8 pages) doi:10.1115/1.1324667 History: Received November 05, 1998; Revised July 24, 2000
Copyright © 2000 by ASME
Your Session has timed out. Please sign back in to continue.

References

Sosin,  D., Sniezek,  J., and Waxweiler,  R., 1995, “Trends in Death Associated With Traumatic Brain Injury, 1979 Through 1992: Success and Failure,” J. Am. Med. Assoc., 273, pp. 1778–1780.
Sosin,  D., Sacks,  J., and Smith,  S., 1989, “Head Injury—Associated Deaths in the United States From 1979–1986,” J. Am. Med. Assoc., 262, pp. 2251–2255.
Pope, A. M., and Tailor, A. R., 1991, Disability in America: Toward a National Agenda for Prevention, National Academy Press, Washington, DC.
Kraus,  J. F., Black,  M. A., Hessol,  N., Ley,  P., Rokaw,  W., Sullivan,  C., Bowers,  S., Knowlton,  S., and Marshall,  L., 1984, “The Incidence of Acute Brain Injury and Serious Impairment in a Defined Population,” Am. J. Epidemiol., 119, pp. 186–201.
Sauaia,  A., Moore,  F. A., Moore,  E. E., Moser,  K. S., Brennan,  R. A., and Pons,  P. T., 1995, “Epidemiology of Trauma Deaths: A Reassessment,” J. Trauma: Inj., Infect., Crit. Care, 38, pp. 185–193.
Adams,  J. H., Doyle,  D., Ford,  I., Gennarelli,  T. A., and Graham,  D. I., 1989, “Diffuse Axonal Injury in Head Injury: Definition, Diagnosis and Grading,” Histopathology, 15, pp. 49–59.
Gennarelli,  T. A., Thibault,  L. E., Adams,  J. H., Graham,  D. I., Thompson,  C. J., and Marcinin,  R. P., 1982, “Diffuse Axonal Injury and Traumatic Coma in the Primate,” Ann. Neurol., 12, pp. 564–574.
Gennarelli, T. A., Segawa, H., Wald, U., Czernicki, Z., Marsh, K., and Thompson, C., 1982, “Physiological Response to Angular Acceleration of the Head,” in: Head Injury: Basic and Clinical Aspects, R. Grossman and P. Gildenberg, eds., Raven Press, New York, pp. 129–140.
Adams, J. H., Gennarelli, T. A., Graham, D. I., Scott, G., and Thibault, L. E., 1983, “Diffuse Axonal Head Injury in Non-Missile Head Injury,” in: Advances in Neurotraumatology, R. Villiani, ed., Excerpta Medica, Amsterdam, pp. 53–58.
Gentleman,  S. M., Roberts,  G. W., Gennarelli,  T. A., Maxwell,  W. L., Adams,  J. H., Kerr,  S., and Graham,  D. I., 1995, “Axonal Injury: A Universal Consequence of Fatal Closed Head Injury?” Acta Neuropathol. (Berl), 89, pp. 537–543.
Gennarelli,  T. A., 1983, “Head Injury in Man and Experimental Animals: Clinical Aspects,” Acta Neurochir., 32, pp. 1–13.
Adams,  J. H., Graham,  D. I., and Gennarelli,  T. A., 1981, “Acceleration Induced Head Injury in the Monkey. II. Neuropathology,” Acta Neuropathol. Suppl. (Berl), 7, pp. 26–28.
Zhou, C., Khalil, T. B., and King, A. I., 1994, “Shear Stress Distribution in the Porcine Brain Due to Rotational Impact,” in: Proc. 38th Stapp Car Crash Conference, SAE, Ft. Lauderdale, FL.
Ruan,  J. S., Khalil,  T., and King,  A. I., 1991, “Human Head Dynamic Response to Side Impact by Finite Element Modeling,” ASME J. Biomech. Eng., 113, pp. 276–283.
Mendis, K., 1992, “Finite Element Modeling of the Brain to Establish Diffuse Axonal Injury Criteria,” thesis, Ohio State University.
Chu,  C. S., Lin,  M. S., Huang,  H. M., and Lee,  M. C., 1993, “Finite Element Analysis of Cerebral Contusion,” J. Biomech., 27, pp. 187–194.
Bandak, F. A., and Eppinger, R. H., 1994, “A Three-Dimensional Finite Element Analysis of the Human Brain Under Combined Rotational and Translational Accelerations,” in: Proc. 38th Stapp Car Crash Conference, SAE, Fort Lauderdale, FL.
Ueno,  K., Melvin,  J. W., Li,  L., and Lighthall,  J. W., 1995, “Development of Tissue Level Brain Injury Criteria by Finite Element Analysis,” J. Neurotrauma, 12, pp. 695–706.
Shreiber, D. I. and Meaney, D. F., 1998, “Finite Element Analysis of Traumatic Brain Injury in the Rat,” ASME J. Biomech. Eng., submitted.
Gray,  J. A. B., and Ritchie,  J. M., 1954, “Effects of Stretch on Single Myelinated Nerve Fibers,” J. Physiol. (Lond), 124, pp. 84–99.
Galbraith,  J. A., Thibault,  L. E., and Matteson,  D. R., 1993, “Mechanical and Electrical Responses of the Squid Giant Axon to Simple Elongation,” ASME J. Biomech. Eng., 115, pp. 13–22.
Haftek,  J., 1970, “Stretch Injury of Peripheral Nerve,” J. Bone Jt. Surg., Br. Vol., 52B, pp. 354–365.
Koike,  H., 1987, “The Extensibility of Aplysia Nerve and the Determination of True Axon Length,” J. Physiol. (Lond), 390, pp. 469–487.
Saatman, K. E., 1993, “An Isolated Single Myelinated Nerve Fiber Model for the Biomechanics of Axonal Injury,” thesis, University of Pennsylvania.
Margulies,  S. S., and Thibault,  L. E., 1992, “A Proposed Tolerance Criterion for Diffuse Axonal Injury in Man,” J. Biomech., 25, pp. 917–923.
Yaghmai,  A., and Povlishock,  J. T., 1992, “Traumatically Induced Reactive Change as Visualized Through the Use of Monoclonal Antibodies Targeted to Neurofilament Subunits,” J. Neuropathol. Exp. Neurol., 51, pp. 158–176.
Sternberger,  L. A., and Sternberger,  N. H., 1983, “Monoclonal Antibodies Distinguish Phosphorylated and Nonphosphorylated Forms of Neurofilaments in situ,” Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 80, pp. 6126–6130.
Ross,  D. T., Meaney,  D. F., Sabol,  M. K., Smith,  D. H., and Gennarelli,  T. A., 1994, “Distribution of Forebrain Diffuse Axonal Injury Following Inertial Closed Head Injury in Miniature Swine,” Exp. Neurol., 126, pp. 291–299.
Grady,  M. S., McLaughlin,  M. R., Christman,  C. W., Valadka,  A. B., Fligner,  C. L., and Povlishock,  J. T., 1993, “The Use of Antibodies Targeted Against the Neurofilament Subunits for the Detection of Diffuse Axonal Injury in Humans,” J. Neuropathol. Exp. Neurol., 52, pp. 143–152.
Gultekin,  S. H., and Smith,  T. W., 1994, “Diffuse Axonal Injury in Craniocerebral Trauma,” Arch. Pathology Laboratory Medicine, 118, pp. 168–171.
Sloan,  K., Stevenson,  J., and Bigbee,  J., 1991, “Qualitative and Quantitative Comparison of the Distribution of Phosphorylated and Non-Phosphorlyated Neurofilament Epitopes Within Central and Peripheral Axons of Adult Hamster (Mesocricetus Auratus),” Cell Tissue Res., 263, pp. 265–270.
Rosenfield,  J., Dorman,  M. E., Griffin,  J. W., Sternberger,  L. A., Sternberger,  N. H., and Price,  D. L., 1987, “Distribution of Neurofilament Antigens After Axonal Injury,” J. Neuropathol. Exp. Neurol., 46, pp. 269–282.
Tomei,  G., Spagnoli,  D., Ducati,  A., Landi,  A., Villani,  R., Fumagalli,  G., Sala,  C., and Gennarelli,  T. A., 1990, “Morphology and Neurophysiology of Focal Axonal Injury Experimentally Induced in the Guinea Pig Optic Nerve,” Acta Neuropathologica, 80, pp. 506–513.
Sokol,  S., 1976, “Visually Evoked Potentials: Theory, Techniques, and Clinical Applications,” Surv. Ophthalmol., 21, pp. 18–44.
Mahapatra,  A. K., and Bhatia,  R., 1989, “Predictive Value of Visual Evoked Potentials in Unilateral Optic Nerve Injury,” Surg. Neurol., 31, pp. 339–342.
Harding,  G., 1984, “A Flash of Light: A Personal Review of 21 Years of Study of the Electrical Activity of the Visual Pathway Beyond the Retina,” Ophthalmic Physiol. Opt., 4, pp. 293–304.
Gennarelli,  T. A., Thibault,  L. E., Tipperman,  R., Tomei,  G., Sergot,  R., Brown,  M., Maxwell,  W. L., Graham,  D. I., Adams,  J. H., Irvine,  A., Gennarelli,  L. M., Duhaime,  A. C., Boock,  R., and Greenberg,  J., 1989, “Axonal Injury in the Optic Nerve: A Model Simulating Diffuse Injury in the Brain,” J. Neurosurg., 71, pp. 244–253.
Creel,  D. J., 1972, “Retinogeniculostriate Projections in Guinea Pigs: Albino and Pigmented Strains Compared,” Exp. Neurol., 36, pp. 411–425.
Creel,  D. J., Dustman,  R. E., and Beck,  E. C., 1973, “Visually Evoked Responses in the Rat, Guinea Pig, Cat, Monkey, and Man,” Exp. Neurol., 40, pp. 351–366.
Ducati,  A., Fava,  E., and Motti,  E. D. F., 1988, “Neuronal Generators of the Visual Evoked Potentials: Intracerebral Recording in Awake Humans,” Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol., 71, pp. 89–99.
Apaydin,  C., Oguz,  Y., Agar,  A., Yargicoglu,  P., Demir,  N., and Aksu,  G., 1993, “Visual Evoked Potentials and Optic Nerve Histopathology in Normal and Diabetic Rates and Effect of Ginkgo Biloba Extract,” Acta Ophthalmol., 71, pp. 623–628.
Suzuki,  M., Sitizyo,  K., Takeuchi,  T., and Saito,  T., 1991, “Visual Evoked Potential From Scalp in Guinea Pigs,” J. Veterinary Medicine Science, 53, pp. 301–305.
Suzuki,  M., Sitizyo,  K., Takeuchi,  T., and Saito,  T., 1991, “Changes in the Visual Evoked Potentials With Different Photic Conditions in Guinea Pigs,” J. Veterinary Medicine Science, 53, pp. 911–915.
Takeuchi,  T., Suzuki,  M., Sitizyo,  K., Isobe,  R., Saito,  T., Umemura,  T., and Shimada,  A., 1992, “Visual Evoked Potentials in Guinea Pigs With Brain Lesion,” J. Veterinary Medicine Science, 54, pp. 813–820.
Altman, D., 1991, Practical Statistics for Medical Research, Chapman & Hall, New York.
Swensen,  S., Silverstein,  M., Ilstrup,  D., Schleck,  C., and Edell,  E., 1997, “The Probability of Malignancy in Solitary Pulmonary Nodules: Application to Small Radiologically Indeterminate Nodules,” Arch. Internal Medicine, 157, pp. 849–855.
Garber,  B., Hebert,  P., Wells,  G., and Yelle,  J., 1996, “Validation of Trauma and Injury Severity Score in Blunt Trauma Patients by Using a Canadian Trauma Registry,” J. Trauma, 40, pp. 733–737.
Shalev,  A., Freedman,  S., Peri,  T., Brandes,  D., and Sahar,  T., 1997, “Predicting PTSD in Trauma Survivors: Prospective Evaluation of Self-Report and Clinician-Administered Instruments,” Br. J. Psychiatry, 170, pp. 558–564.
Ukimura,  O., Troncoso,  P., Ramirez,  E., and Babaian,  R., 1998, “Prostate Cancer Staging: Correlation Between Ultrasound Determined Tumor Contact Length and Pathologically Confirmed Extraprostatic Extension,” J. Urol., 159, pp. 1251–1259.
Varela,  A., Bosco Lopez Saez,  J., and Quintela Senra,  D., 1997, “Serum Ceruloplasmin as a Diagnostic Marker of Cancer,” Cancer Lett., 121, pp. 139–145.
Bytzer,  P., Moller Hansen,  J., Schaffalitzky de Muckadell,  B., and Malchow-Moller,  A., 1997, “Predicting Endoscopic Diagnosis in the Dyspeptic Patient: The Value of Predictive Score Models,” Scand. J. Gastroenterol., 32, pp. 118–125.
Allaouchiche,  B., Jaumain,  H., Dumontet,  C., and Motin,  J., 1996, “Early Diagnosis of Ventilator-Associated Pneumonia: Is It Possible to Define a Cutoff Value of Infected Cells in BAL Fluid?” Chest, 110, pp. 1558–1565.
Peipert,  J., Boardman,  L., Hogan,  J., Sung,  J., and Mayer,  K., 1996, “Laboratory Evaluation of Acute Upper Genital Tract Infection,” Obstet. Gynecol. (N.Y.), 87, pp. 730–736.
Pastor,  A., Menendez,  R., Cremades,  M., Pastor,  V., Llopis,  R., and Aznar,  J., 1997, “Diagnostic Value of SCC, CEA, and CYFRA 21.1 in Lung Cancer: A Bayesian Analysis,” Eur. Respir. J., 10, pp. 603–609.
Duke,  T., Butt,  W., and South,  M., 1997, “Predictors of Mortality and Multiple Organ Failure in Children With Sepsis,” Intensive Care Med., 23, pp. 684–692.
Fijten,  G., Starmans,  R., Muris,  J., Schouten,  H., Blijham,  G., and Knottnerus,  J., 1995, “Predictive Value of Signs and Symptoms for Colorectal Cancer in Patients With Rectal Bleeding in General Practice,” Fam. Pract., 12, pp. 279–286.
Einstein,  A., Bodian,  C., and Gil,  J., 1997, “The Relationships Among Performance Measures in the Selection of Diagnostic Tests,” Arch. Pathol. Lab Med., 121, pp. 110–117.
Diamond,  G., 1992, “Clinical Epistemology of Sensitivity and Specificity,” J. Clin. Epidemiol., 45, pp. 9–13.
Hajian-Tilaki,  K., Hanley,  J., Joseph,  L., and Collet,  J., 1997, “A Comparison of Parametric and Nonparametric Approaches to ROC Analysis of Quantitative Diagnostic Tests,” Med. Decis Making, 17, pp. 94–102.
MacKillop,  W., and Quirt,  C., 1997, “Measuring the Accuracy of Prosnostic Judgments in Oncology,” J. Clin. Epidemiol., 50, pp. 21–29.
Heshner, D., and Johnson, L. W., 1981, Applied Discrete Choice Modeling, Croom Helm, London.
Steinberg, D., and Colla, P., 1991, LOGIT: A Supplementary Module for SYSTAT, SYSTAT, Inc., Chicago.
Sima,  A. A. F., Zhang,  W. X., Cherian,  P. V., and Chakrabarti,  S., 1992, “Impaired Visual Evoked Potential and Primary Axonopathy of the Optic Nerve in the Diabetic BB/W-Rat,” Diabetologia, 35, pp. 602–607.
Myers, B., Van Ee, C., Camacho, D., Woolley, C., and Best, T., 1995, “On the Structural and Material Properties of Mammalian Skeletal Muscle and Its Relevance to Human Cervical Impact Dynamics,” in: Proc. 39th Stapp Car Crash Conference, SAE, Coronado, CA.
Myers, B. S., Best, T. M., Wooley, C. T., and Camacho, D. L., 1994, “Measurement of Large Strain in Skeletal Muscle,” in: Proc. 22nd Annual International Workshop on Human Subjects for Biomechanical Research, Fort Lauderdale, FL.
Carrington Reid,  M., Lane,  D., and Feinstein,  A., 1998, “Academic Calculations Versus Clinical Judgments: Practicing Physicians’ Use of Quantitative Measurements of Test Accuracy,” Am. J. Med., 104, pp. 374–380.
Brenneman,  F., Boulanger,  B., McLellan,  B., and Redelmeier,  D., 1998, “Measuring Injury Severity: Time for a Change?” J. Trauma, 44, pp. 580–582.
Fine, B., and Yanoff, M., 1979, Ocular Histology, 2nd ed., Harper & Row, New York.
McIntosh,  T. K., Smith,  D. H., Meaney,  D. F., Kotapka,  M. J., and Graham,  D. I., 1996, “Neuropathological Sequelae of Traumatic Brain Injury: Relationship to Neurochemical and Biomechanical Mechanisms,” Lab. Invest., 74, pp. 315–342.
Ommaya, A. K., Yarnell, P., Hirsch, A. E., and Harris, E. H., 1967, “Scaling of Experimental Data on Cerebral Concussion in Sub-Human Primates to Concussion Threshold for Man,” in: Proc. 13th Stapp Car Crash Conference, SAE, Anaheim, CA.
Bain, A. C., Billiar, K. L., Shreiber, D. I., McIntosh, T. K., and Meaney, D. F., 1996, “In Vivo Mechanical Thresholds for Traumatic Axonal Damage,” in: AGARD Specialists Meeting, Mescalero, NM.

Figures

Grahic Jump Location
Schematic of the guinea pig optic nerve stretch model. Elongation is triggered by a solenoid and is measured by a linear variable differential transformer (LVDT). The magnitude of the displacement is controlled by a micromanipulator. The force experienced by the nerve is measured by a strain gauge force transducer aligned in series with the optic nerve. The force transducer is also used in conjunction with a digital multimeter to apply a preload to the optic nerve prior to the experiment.
Grahic Jump Location
(A) Schematic of the in situ experiments showing the placement of markers along the length of the nerve, the fixed reference point on the base of the skull, and the end point that is anatomically fixed to the base of the skull. (B) Schematic showing the gage length of the optic nerve (lin), and the measured displacement of the optic nerve after stretch. (C) Schematic of the right optic nerve demonstrating the three areas—retinal, middle, and chiasmatic—used to evaluate the strain uniformity in the nerve.
Grahic Jump Location
Representation of the conservative (A) and liberal (B) thresholds calculated for morphological and functional injury. Below the conservative threshold, no nerves will be injured; therefore, there are no false negatives and the threshold achieves a sensitivity of 1.0. Above the liberal threshold, all nerves will exhibit injury and therefore there are no false positives, yielding a specificity of 1.0.
Grahic Jump Location
Results of the in situ displacement-stretch experiments. The mean measured nerve displacements (dark circles) were plotted versus the applied ocular displacement. Linear regression was used to develop a relationship (R=0.99) between the applied displacement and resulting net displacement of the optic nerve; predicted nerve displacements fell within one standard deviation of measured for all but one level of ocular displacement.
Grahic Jump Location
(A,B) Longitudinal optic nerve sections injured at 7 mm and stained with NF68, a marker for axonal pathology. Injured nerves exhibited clusters of retraction bulbs (black arrows) and axonal swellings (white arrows) near the retina and 1–2 mm from the chiasm. (C) Longitudinal section injured at 8 mm and stained with SMI32. At higher injury levels, degeneration fragments were observed. (D) Longitudinal section of an uninjured nerve stained with SMI32. Bar: (A) 40 μm, (B) 20 μm, (C,D) 40 μm.
Grahic Jump Location
Logit analysis of morphological injury data. Nerves were labeled either injured (probability=1) or uninjured (probability=0) based on the presence or absence of morphological injury. Logit parameters were estimated with very high significance (likelihood ratio test, chi-squared, p<0.0001). The results of this analysis were used to define a conservative threshold (E11=0.14, 95 percent confidence limits (CL)=0.04, 0.18), a liberal threshold (E11=0.34, CL=0.16, 0.24), and the best, or optimal threshold (E11=0.21, CL=0.30, 0.42) for morphological injury.

Tables

Errata

Discussions

Some tools below are only available to our subscribers or users with an online account.

Related Content

Customize your page view by dragging and repositioning the boxes below.

Related Journal Articles
Related eBook Content
Topic Collections

Sorry! You do not have access to this content. For assistance or to subscribe, please contact us:

  • TELEPHONE: 1-800-843-2763 (Toll-free in the USA)
  • EMAIL: asmedigitalcollection@asme.org
Sign In